Science Machine · PCOS, audited

Do PCOS papers say how they measured things?

When a paper reports a testosterone level, an insulin-resistance score or an ovary scan, does it say which assay, formula or criterion produced the value?

38.4%

of reported values (201 of 524) come with no stated method. Papers published 2016 to 2026. Interval, resampling whole papers: 29.3 to 47.9. experiments/measurand_tiers/repass/REPORT_v3.md:18-19

45 of 98 papers (46%) leave out at least one method. experiments/measurand_tiers/repass/REPORT_v3.md:20

A formula is not a measurement. An insulin-resistance score such as HOMA-IR counts as stated only if the paper also names the insulin assay behind it; a free androgen index needs the testosterone and SHBG methods. For ovary scans, "an ultrasound was done" is not enough: the paper must give a criterion or the equipment. These rules were written after the pilot results were seen, and both push values towards "not stated". experiments/measurand_tiers/repass/REPORT_v3.md:46-55,134-135

ReadingNot statedRate
Main reading (formula rule on; a citation alone counts as not stated)201/52438.4%
Without the formula rule179/52434.2%
Lenient: a cited methods paper counts as stated183/52434.9%
experiments/measurand_tiers/repass/REPORT_v3.md:25-29

By what was measured

Papers 2016 to 2026. Small numbers throughout: one or two papers move a row by several points.

MeasureValuesNot stated%
Testosterone551730.9%
Luteinising hormone502244.0%
Fasting insulin492040.8%
Follicle-stimulating hormone482245.8%
Insulin resistance481735.4%
Estradiol331751.5%
Sex hormone binding globulin29931.0%
Polycystic ovarian morphology (scan)271037.0%
Free androgen index241041.7%
Hirsutism24312.5%
LH/FSH ratio241354.2%
Anti-Müllerian hormone191052.6%
DHEA sulfate19842.1%
Progesterone14857.1%
Rows with 14 or more values shown; the full table is in the source. experiments/measurand_tiers/repass/REPORT_v3.md:89-105

Hormone assays (LH, FSH, estradiol, AMH, progesterone) are left out about half the time. Clinical scores such as hirsutism rarely are. Without the formula rule, every insulin-resistance score counted as stated because the formula was named; with it, about a third have no insulin assay behind them. experiments/measurand_tiers/repass/REPORT_v3.md:112-116

Limits